tl;dr:
4K:
- Sharpness: 0
- Super Resolution: Off
Anything else:
- Sharpness: 12
- Super Resolution: Low
Explanation:
0 sharpness passes through the image untouched, which would normally be desirable, but not when the upscaler has produced an image that is far from untouched. PC mode with RGB input is the only time the upscaler results could be considered untouched.
10 sharpness applies an anti-aliasing filter, but does NOT apply any actual sharpening. Counter-intuitively, 10 sharpness is effectively softer than 0 sharpness.
Smooth Gradation set to Low adds additional softening and some debanding, so you may want it set, but I find the loss of noise and detail too unpleasant and instead keep it off. It is bad at its intended purpose of smoothing gradients, other than in heavily compressed content.
The effect of Super Resolution is diminished until sharpness is raised above 10. 12 is a reasonable middle ground to get the super resolution effect without introducing traditional sharpness artifacts that exist in settings above 10, but you could go as high as 15 or 20 depending on taste. Raising the sharpness also reduces the difference between areas of excessive sharpening from the upscaler and the rest of the picture. I find a mildly oversharpened picture more pleasing to the eye than a picture with specific areas of oversharpness.
Previously this guide recommended Super Resolution set to Medium, but on reflection I have determined this creates an unnatural rough-looking texture on skin in HD sources, and accentuates artifacts in SD. Low looks more comparable to madVR and professional upscales (DCI 2K upscaled ('fake') 4K Bluray releases).
PC mode applies a more basic upscaling algorithm and effectively disables the AI upscaling. It is the only way of controlling (disabling) the AI upscaling. You can verify if PC mode is engaged properly as the settings for Noise Reduction and Smooth Gradation should be greyed out. In PC mode at 1440p or less you can consider setting sharpness to 0 or 10 (0 for passthrough, 10 for anti-aliasing) instead of 12. For video games I stick with 12.
My target with these settings is to get upscaled inputs looking somewhere between trivial upscaling algorithms and madVR. Even text content being fed to the TV at 1080p/1440p looks better with these settings - they work for all cases.
Comments
Hi, when you say 4K, do you also mean 4K on streaming services like Apple TV and Netflix, or are these considered too compressed and could benefit from sharpness 12 and super resolution?
Hello, never got an answer to my comment so I’m just rep-posting it since I posted it 6 months ago. Thanks:
Hey, sorry if you answered this and I am misunderstanding…but what exactly does the Super Resolution feature do? It is an anti aliasing feature? What happens if you use sharpness 10 or 12 but keep super resolution off?
I was under the impression that if you keep sharpeness at 0, and super resolution “off”, then it just uses the basic upscaler? But you’re saying that only happens in PC RGB mode? Can you explain a little more about these things?
Hey, sorry if you answered this and I am misunderstanding…but what exactly does the Super Resolution feature do? It is an anti aliasing feature? What happens if you use sharpness 10 or 12 but keep super resolution off?
I was under the impression that if you keep sharpeness at 0, and super resolution “off”, then it just uses the basic upscaler? But you’re saying that only happens in PC RGB mode? Can you explain a little more about these things?
Hey dark,
What about Noise reduction, mpeg noise reduction and smooth gradation for 1080p upscaled and 4K native?
Always off for all content
I always thought AI picture pro was the upscaler. All I see with super resolution is that the radius of the sharpening increases. Is it also upscaling the resolution?
I find sharpness at 20 best for hdr and Dolby vision 4k content. I went back and forth multiple times but could get satisfied with sharpness at 10 for hdr4k content. Somehow the picture looks soft. That being said for 1080p sdr sharpness at 10 seems good.
I’ve updated the post with a simpler tl;dr taking into account my latest findings. I no longer bother differentiating settings between PC mode and non-PC mode – only by 4K or non-4K.
10 is a fine setting for 1080p. Better than 0. But I still recommend 12 and low super resolution.
For 4K the only correct setting is 0. There is no subjectivity when displaying at 1:1 resolution. Not surprised you couldn’t get used to 10 as it will soften the image. The answer is to set to 0, not 20.
Hi, what would you recommend if the content is being upscaled at source? For example, a 1080 Blu-ray upscaled to 4K by the player? Because the feed going into the TV is still technically 4K.
In this scenario I would usually choose 0